26th May 2018
Established 1872. Online since 1996.

Clickimin set for £1.5 million revamp as part of new AHS project

Click to enlarge

Looking down towards the proposed Anderson High School site at the Staney Hill.

Clickimin Leisure Centre is in line for a £1.5 million extension and refurbishment so it can house the new Anderson High School’s PE department.

Shetland Recreational Trust (SRT) has agreed in principle to sell the neighbouring parcel of land hosting its campsite, though negotiations on the fine detail are continuing.

While haggling with the SIC over the sale price, the SRT also has to weigh up the benefits of Clickimin being revamped and extended – and the guaranteed income a 25-year “service level agreement” for the local authority to use the leisure complex would bring.

SIC children’s services director Helen Budge told councillors on Wednesday that, as an all-new PE department was not needed, the figure of “roughly” £1.5 million could come from within the overall £36 million budget for a school and halls of residence.

Mrs Budge said a Clickimin extension could include a new 200 square metre gym hall, along with funding to make alterations to existing parts of the building.

“We need a number of PE areas, but also it would be for the public to use other areas that we are not utilising,” Mrs Budge told members of the education and families committee.

It is hoped an agreement between the SIC and SRT can be ironed out in the next three months.

AHS pupils would not require exclusive use of Clickimin’s swimming pool, bowls hall or squash courts. All would continue to operate as normal. The new gym hall could also be made available to the general public in evenings and at weekends.

Councillor Peter Campbell pointed out that the benefits the SRT stands to gain “could influence the whole question of purchase of land”.

Detailed site investigations have been conducted looking at precisely where the accompanying halls of residence will go. Mrs Budge said the project team had to work around an area of “contaminated” land which used to host the town’s dump.

But she remains hopeful that the first turf will be turned in March 2014, in line with the Scottish Government’s quick-fire timetable.

Two-thirds of the project cost is being met by the Scottish Government – though North Isles councillor Gary Cleaver said he had “grave concerns” about the financial model.

He claimed the “design, build, finance and maintain” arrangement with Hubco North was akin to a re-branding of the discredited Private Finance Initiative (PFI) model used for big building projects.

Though his fears are “partly tempered” by other councillors’ “overwhelming will” to see the new school built, Mr Cleaver fears members will be asked to sanction an eight-figure spend in “blind faith”.

“I’ve always been told that it’s not [a re-branded PFI model],” he said. “However, at their first meeting the senior representatives of Hubco North… unequivocally replied ‘yes it is’.

“Only time will tell, but we are committing in the region of £12 million… and as yet we have no clear understanding of the additional costs [in maintenance]. This could be viewed as blind faith in years to come.”

Mr Cleaver added there was “no such thing as free money”, also querying why the new AHS, with a 1,200-pupil capacity, “has to sit within the top 10 per cent of largest secondary schools” in the country.

But Mrs Budge said this was the third round of the Scottish Government’s “schools for the future” programme. She believes “lessons have been learned” and arrangements for maintaining new buildings were “not nearly as rigid as before”.

Finance chief James Gray said the council would be responsible for day-to-day things such as painting and replacing light bulbs and carpets – just as it would if it took out a long-term lease on a building. A contractor would carry out larger scale tasks such as replacing boilers.

“At the end of the 25 years the school is handed over to us as good as new, effectively,” Mr Gray said.

Councillor Frank Robertson noted it was now 30 years since the first report recommending a new school at Clickimin. He was more sanguine about the project’s prospects of success, pointing out “reputable” and “experienced” national companies were to design and build the school.

Religious representative Martin Tregonning said that, though “strictly speaking” it was not a PFI contract, “many elements are very similar”.

He said he hoped there would be no repeat of “stuff-ups” under PFI, such as the hospital built without an X-Ray room and frequent post-construction problems with the cost of maintenance.

“There’s always the law of unintended consequences,” Mr Tregonning said. “There’s no desire to enter into a contract which is going to be a rod for our own back in the future. The more people look at it and scrutinise it and come back with positive suggestions, the better chance we have of making this a successful project.”

Tags:

About Neil Riddell

View other stories by »

5 comments

  1. Colin Pearson

    Now it makes sense …… yeah lets sell off Freefield Center and Viewforth House get rid of the quiet voiced minority and we may be able to keep our gold plated fittings.
    Haven forbid us Councillors should move to a council building center based at Gremista….if the council have 15 buildings in Lerwick it means they have 15 receptionists saying “hello can i help you”…move to a one meets all center and you need 1 receptionist……..14 care workers jobs saved…people first or profit? they are looking after the wrong people.

    Reply
  2. Douglas Young

    Bet the parents and teachers fighting to save their rural schools didn’t see that one coming. Clever use of Education Budget

    Reply
  3. Johan Adamson

    Bang goes the money saved from moving the school to be next to the leisure centre. Cant they make use of existing gym halls? A walk to the knab would be fine for the older pupils and great excersise – we used to walk to the swimming pool / Bells Brae / the hospital. We didnt get bused around the place. A fine training for university where things are not right next door and pupils have to be responsible.

    Despite assurances, I would still be worried this is PFI. There is no such thing as money for nothing if the scheme is run commercially – why would they? We’d be better off if SLAP (our own finance/ leasing company) paid for the building and leased it back – would we not? This is not a grant.

    Reply
  4. David Spence

    What stagger’s me is the huge amount of money that has already been spent on the New School for Lerwick before 1 brick has yet been layed. I suspect the same amount of money wasted, so far, could have been used for this ‘ revamp ‘ at the Clickimin.

    No doubt the Council will be wanting to spend thousands on a feasibility study, again, to see if this latest ‘ brainwave ‘ of competent assessors deem this idea viable. lol

    Reply
  5. Jim Leask

    @Colin – What exactly does the development of a much needed new school to service the whole of Shetland have to do with Council offices?

    @Douglas – Surely it makes sense to build a new school by accessing two thirds of the funding from the Scottish government? I’m not saying the SIC have always amde the best choices in how to spent their money but it seems they are damned if they do and damned if they don’t!

    Can we not all get behind a project to deliver a much needed new high school to Shetland….and yes it will be for Shetland not just Lerwick! A huge input of money is being taken into the isles to build the school with a minimal outlay from Council coffers compared to what it may have originally cost us.

    Mistakes were made with the new AHS at the Knab fiasco but surely solid plans are now in place to deliver what Shetland needs. Without a doubt, there will be legions of people linking this new school to Mareel, Freefield, Viking Energy, Da Charitable Trust, past plans for new schools, Da Norrona and every other past negative experience or whatever they have an axe to grind about.

    I for one applaud the hard work that has been put in over the last peerie while to try and deliver this new school to Shetland….well done to those invovled.

    Reply

Your Comment

Please note, it is the policy of The Shetland Times to publish comments and letters from named individuals only. Both forename and surname are required.

Comments are moderated. Contributors must observe normal standards of decency and tolerance for the opinions of others.

The views expressed are those of contributors and not of The Shetland Times.

The Shetland Times reserves the right to decline or remove any contribution without notice or stating reason.

Comments are limited to 200 words but please email longer articles or letters to editorial@shetlandtimes.co.uk for consideration and include a daytime telephone number and your address. If emailing information in confidence please put "Not for publication" in both the subject line and at the top of the main message.