In tests, eight out of 10 folk said they preferred wheelie bins

Wheelie bins have elicited a hugely positive response from the bulk of people who took part in a two-week trial run, according to an SIC survey. The council is preparing to provide the bins to anyone who wants them in Lerwick and Scalloway.

Thirty domestic and commercial premises in Lerwick’s Goodlad Crescent and Commercial Street and Scalloway’s Main Street took part in the experiment in June this year. The survey showed 85 per cent of respondents felt wheelie bins were a good idea, while 90 per cent found them easy to use and 85 per cent said they would use the bins in the future if they were made available.

The council is now to spend £125,000 on purchasing 1,200 new bins, with sizes of 120 litres, 240 litres and 360 litres being made available to householders at a one-off cost of £34.50. A new vehicle capable of handling the bins has been purchased at a cost of £125,000.

The bins will be made available to householders from February and to commercial premises, with various sizes up to 1,100 litres, from 1st April. Commercial users will pay a unit charge based on the size of the bin they choose and the council is claiming that around six in every 10 small businesses will pay less than they currently do for refuse collection.

The new essy kert will still collect rubbish from householders who choose not to buy one of the wheelie bins, contrary to fears from some that there would have to be two separate collection runs.

Wheelie bins have proved to be a contentious issue in many areas when they are first introduced, including in Edinburgh when executive director of infrastructure Gordon Greenhill brought them in. But SIC staff hope the fact that this scheme is voluntary will mean people won’t find too many causes for complaint.

Some areas, including the lanes leading off Commercial Street and other steep, exposed areas of the town, have been ruled unsuitable for the bins. Council officials are anticipating uptake of somewhere in the region of 1,000 bins, amounting to 30 per cent of the 3,000 or so householders in Lerwick and Scal­loway. It is initially to be on a “first come, first served” basis and if the scheme proves a success it may require additional investment from the council in order to expand further.

Some respondents in the survey questioned the wisdom of having the bins in such an exposed, windy climate and others raised concerns about the practicability of cleaning particularly the larger bins.

Follow­ing a presentation at this week’s Lerwick Community Council from SIC cleansing service manager Jon­a­­­than Emptage, some members suggested that finding a way of bolting the bins down, or simply putting a rock in the bottom, would be enough to deal with the wind problem.

Jonathan Wills said that while one of his Lerwick South constit­uents was “extremely angry” about their introduction, many others seemed to be broadly in favour. Others suggested it might be possible for the SIC to cover the £34.50 unit cost because it might be a “false economy” to charge for them. While it may not seem a particularly substantial sum for many, it could be quite a lot for someone on a low income, it was noted.


Add Your Comment
  • mrs.C. Donald

    • November 12th, 2009 21:34

    The subject of charging £34.50 for wheelie bins by SIC should be questioned.
    Down south on the East coast area and elsewhere the wheelie bins belong to the Council and are not removed if moving home ( which would be the case if considered private property). They can be hooked on a fixture against wind and enclosed shelter. Some bins have house no. painted on and smaller sizes to accomodate the elderly, etc..
    On the mainland it is the householder who can hose out and clean bin, or hire a company that does this for you as it is only disenfectant pressure hosing.
    There is the problem of the weather and some bins blown around but not if sensibly secure at collection points.
    Why think about Edinburgh?, Wheelie bins have been around for a long time in all areas and surprised that it takes a meeting to figure it out.

  • J. James

    • November 13th, 2009 4:14

    Wheelie bins are great, we have used one for years. I just recently bought Binifresh at ASDA so the bin would stop smelling and attracting foxes and rats. It has worked really well. Since i installed Binifresh the bin smells great and not a sign of vermin.

    Best of luck,


  • W Conroy

    • November 13th, 2009 4:25

    As an ex Lerwick resident now living in Edinburgh I use a wheelie bin.
    The wind is not really a problem for our bins even in the windier streets as the bins are actually quite heavy. Our problems come more from drunken idiots making off with the bins or kicking them about the streets, if the council (like here in Edinburgh) decide they won’t collect anything that is outside a bin, petty arguments between neighbours over some putting things in other peoples bins and kids setting fire to bins or placing fireworks in them.
    Thankfully we do not have to buy our bins as it could become quite expensive for some residents, especially for those that are at work all day only to come home to find their bin stolen or damaged. If you start to charge people for these bins you may end up with people stealing bins to replace theirs!
    I still say that wheelie bins are a good idea (especially with the seagull problems there) but in my opinion to charge people for them will only end up causing more issues than its worth!


Add Your Comment

Please note, it is the policy of The Shetland Times to publish comments and letters from named individuals only. Both forename and surname are required.

Comments are moderated. Contributors must observe normal standards of decency and tolerance for the opinions of others.

The views expressed are those of contributors and not of The Shetland Times.

The Shetland Times reserves the right to decline or remove any contribution without notice or stating reason.

Comments are limited to 200 words but please email longer articles or letters to for consideration and include a daytime telephone number and your address. If emailing information in confidence please put "Not for publication" in both the subject line and at the top of the main message.

200 words left

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


Get Latest News in Your Inbox

Join the The Shetland Times mailing list to get one daily email update at midday on what's happening in Shetland.