The woes of Tavish (Charlie Gallagher)

Judge me on what I have done. Those were the words of Tavish Scott when interviewed on radio and television.

Well the short answer is precious little that is worthy but a great deal that is less than expected from our MSP.

To understand what a calamitous failure Tavish has been in his life in politics one has to start at the beginning.

As a councillor he was a failure and his one claim to notoriety was his involvement in the Nick Reiter affair, which he has never explained.

He then moved his incompetence to the Scottish Parliament in 1999. Here he proved himself to be not very good at very much with one notable exception. He showed that he was a brilliant property speculator, pocketing himself a tidy sum from his investments in the Edinburgh property market, all this was done with yours and my money, not his own.

Before last May’s election Nick Clegg said that if he found out that any of his party had profited in such a way at the expense of the public purse he would throw them out. But we all know just how good Nick’s word is, to name tuition fees for example.

What else has Tavish done, or should I say who else has Tavish betrayed?

Remember well the day he stood with our fishermen who were blockading Sullom Voe. Remember him standing there proclaiming: “Brothers, I am backing you all the way and I’ll vote against any deal that affects your livelihoods.”

Then off he scarpers back to Edinburgh and promptly votes against his brothers of a few hours before. Yes that is the kind of brother no-one wants.

In his party, Tavish, and others, are accused of being control freaks. He demonstrates this by his petulance and dismissive approach to the ideas of others; if Tavish didn’t think of it, then it’s no good.

Take council tax where we in the SNP had an idea, which in my view was not perfect but it was a start. Now Tavish and his Lib Dems had a different idea but would he discuss a compromise? No, it had to be Tavish’s scheme or nothing and so off he stomped.

Then we had Alex Salmond making a perfectly good proposal that if Westminster wants to close our coastguard stations then the Scottish government should be allowed to take them over. But Tavish thought that this seemed too much like independent thinking and action so once again he stomped off.

He reminds me of the spoilt brat in the school playground with the only football and who if you didn’t let him play where he wanted to, picked up his ball and ran off.

Another matter that needs explanation is the current fuel price rip-off. While it is not a Scottish Parliament responsibility we all feel the effects of the Con/Dems’ total and complete lethargy in this matter.

The Con/Dems fall guy Danny Alexander comes away with a load of Westminster gobbledygook, trying to give the impression that they are full of enthusiasm to get us cheaper fuel and that they are working their collective socks off trying to persuade Brussels of the merits of their request. What a load of twaddle they have been telling you over the past 11 months and a bit.

I spoke with a very good friend of mine who works at the heart of the Brussels bureaucracy and they told me that as this type of request was nothing knew and was already in operation then if the Con/Dems had applied at the very outset of their administration we could have been enjoying cheaper fuel since about last July.

Yes the Lib Dems have been a lot of help and what they have really shown once again is that they are not to be trusted at any level of government. Once again they have demonstrated that they are happy to throw away their so-called principles for the nice comfy seat of a government limo.

So there you have a few snippets and I could with a little more time fill this paper with Tavish’s shortcomings, but at the end of the day it is down to you to judge. On 5th May you will have your chance to make that judgment. So what are your alternatives?

You could choose Labour, who got the country into the mess in the first place, or you could choose Tory but you already have a Tory standing, that is according to Tavish himself. This leaves Jean Urquhart who has been a hard-working councillor in her adopted Ullapool where she is also a successful hotelier and knows full well the needs of island life.

She knows of the need to preserve our fishing industry, the need for a successful and affordable tourist industry, and the absolute need for excellent transport links. She is also a stalwart supporter of the retention of both Stornoway and Lerwick coastguard stations.

Finally, if you decide a plague on all our political houses then you could choose Billy Fox, an honest and ardent campaigner against the massive windfarm development proposed for Shetland.

At the end of the day it is down to you. But whichever way you decide please, please go out and vote. And if you are considering not voting, just remember that there are people not all that different from us who are currently dying on the streets of Libyan towns and cities just for the democratic right to vote.

Charlie Gallagher
SNP member
Tigh Na Mara,


Add Your Comment
  • Colin Hunter

    • April 13th, 2011 12:10

    Well said that man!

  • Malcolm Cole

    • April 13th, 2011 12:21

    Ha Ha Ha. Mr Gallagher says he met a man in a pub who said he worked in Brussels and he said the Commission could work really fast on something! Fast work from the Commission has never happened since joining the EEC in 1973! And it looks like the rest of this column has been made up too

  • douglas young

    • April 13th, 2011 19:59

    Good on ye boy! Was voting SNP again onywye as they promised and delivered zero prescription charges. Tavish supports the Windfarm but keeps quiet about it afore the election, terrible behaviour from someen asked tae represent the people o Shetland.

  • Stuart Stenhouse

    • April 16th, 2011 12:20

    A letter that makes for splendid entertaining reading; albeit with a serious message.

    Coincidentally, the Lib-Dem election leaflet landed on my door mat yesterday. 5 images of Charles Kennedy (former Lib-Dem leader, no connection with Shetland), 1 image of Tavish; and no reference to Nick Clegg, Deputy Prime Minister.

    Is the CON-DEM tie-up so toxic that Tavish does not even acknowledge their existance?

  • ali inkster

    • April 18th, 2011 16:55

    Let me see will I vote for some one who has probably only ever seen Shetland on the weather map and is going to be confused by the time it takes her flight to get here when she arrives for the first and probably last ever visit to Shetland. The short answer is no.
    A slightly longer answer is I don’t trust the SNP to deliver for Shetland, their choice of candidate who has no connection to our islands shows just how little regard they have for us.
    But then their other choice of candidate was the Fat controller nominated by the Millers.

  • Colin Hunter

    • April 18th, 2011 18:50

    What came o’ Willie Ross?

  • ali inkster

    • April 18th, 2011 19:34

    Who cares?

  • Geordie Hunter

    • April 19th, 2011 3:59

    Tak some tablets Ali!

  • Willie Ross

    • April 19th, 2011 10:02

    I’m still here!


Add Your Comment

Please note, it is the policy of The Shetland Times to publish comments and letters from named individuals only. Both forename and surname are required.

Comments are moderated. Contributors must observe normal standards of decency and tolerance for the opinions of others.

The views expressed are those of contributors and not of The Shetland Times.

The Shetland Times reserves the right to decline or remove any contribution without notice or stating reason.

Comments are limited to 200 words but please email longer articles or letters to for consideration and include a daytime telephone number and your address. If emailing information in confidence please put "Not for publication" in both the subject line and at the top of the main message.

200 words left

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


Get Latest News in Your Inbox

Join the The Shetland Times mailing list to get one daily email update at midday on what's happening in Shetland.