Wreckers should resign (Jonathan Wills)

I learned with astonishment that the SIC convener and vice-convener, along with other members of the council’s so-called leadership, have signed a motion seeking to undo the decision to transfer Scalloway School’s secondary 1-4 pupils to the Anderson High School.

The Full Council took this decision after an exhaustive consultation, extensive research and a democratic debate. The government’s Inspectors of Education backed it. I can understand why local members seeking re-election might wish to wreck this process, and why some senior retiring members might want to give them a leg up, in hopes of perpetuating the present regime beyond its absurd conclusion next May.

However, when these local members are also on the new SIC executive committee, surely their commitment to the good of Shetland as a whole must come first? If they will put ward interests first, it is open to them to resign from the executive. That would be the honourable course. To try to throw everything into confusion, less than a month before the first pupils are due to transfer to Lerwick, shows a contempt for democracy and an alarming disregard for the welfare of the pupils.

Council staff are already implementing the decision to transfer these pupils to the AHS, where they’ll join Scalloway’s secondary 5 and 6 students at one of the best schools in Britain. Anderson High teachers have been working hard to welcome the new intake. Scalloway parents who’ve been involved are, I’m told, agreeably surprised by what they’ve found at the AHS, after all the scare stories they’d been fed by protest organisers. This is a very good school, a happy school and a welcoming school. It does have room for the extra pupils. Admittedly, its buildings are not ideal but that’s why we’re building a new AHS at Lower Staney Hill – another democratic decision that some may still hope to sabotage.

Those executive committee members who’re aiding and abetting this wrecking motion are completely irresponsible. They haven’t suggested where else savings could come from, if Scalloway’s secondary department remains open. That’s because they either have no idea or dare not say. Of course, the savings would have to come from lower budgets for all Shetland schools, and from the closure of more rural primary schools.

What on earth will the Accounts Commission make of this? Almost a year after they investigated the council’s habitual indecision, lamentable lack of leadership and serial failure to implement democratic decisions, the auditors will see that the ruling group has learned no lessons and made no real changes. They will find that the council’s supposedly reformed government is but a cynical façade, covering up the same old shambles. In that case they and the new Scottish local government minister have a further option to bring this bunch of clowns to heel: they can send in commissioners to run the council. That is possible, although not yet probable. If it happens, we’ll see the resources for our schools slashed to national minimum standards. And there’ll be no-one to blame for the ensuing wreckage but witless councillors who haven’t got the gumption to make difficult decisions and stick by them.

Cllr Jonathan Wills
Town Hall,


Add Your Comment
  • Colin Hunter

    • May 4th, 2011 20:31

    Well said Jonathan! It’s high time some members of the council learned how to abide by, and implement decisions that are taken in the chamber. There’s too much back tracking and procrastination going on and all it serves to do is make you look like a bunch of ditherers! If they make a decision they should just get on with it and DO it regardless how unpopular it may seem at the time. People will often forgive unpopular decisions if it is proved they were what was done was necessary, but they will never forgive behind the scenes jiggery pokery by people seeking to further their own ends. I have said this before and I’ll say it again. Come to a decision and then get on with it!

  • James Stewart

    • May 4th, 2011 20:52

    I agree with Jonathan. It seems a bit brash after deciding to close the schools to suddenly come back on the decision. What makes it worse is the total disregard for the parents, bairns and those who campaigned against the closure – offering them false hope, no less.

    The biggest problem with this council has been unity and communication – the lack of it!

  • Christopher Ritch

    • May 5th, 2011 9:06

    Jonathan Wills did much the same with his campaign to stop the new AHS being built at the Knab. Some might say “Pot, meet kettle” but I say if the Council has made a bad decision the right thing to do is attempt to change it.

  • Ted Knight

    • May 7th, 2011 10:07

    Comment moderator’s,or thought police permitting, i support Jonathan Wills one hundred percent.

    Now, where he heck IS that Shetland Money Tree?

  • Colin Hunter

    • May 7th, 2011 19:02

    The time to change or influence a “bad” decision is before the vote is taken, thereby trying to ensure a better outcome. We can’t all cry for another election today just because we may not like the result that came from Thursdays one. You can please some of the people some of the time……….Etc!

  • Christopher Ritch

    • May 9th, 2011 8:17

    Indeed Colin, and as Jonathan points out there was an expensive consultation for people to do just that. He also claims there was a “democratic debate” although I am not sure how ignoring the feedback from the expensive consultation can be described as “democratic” ? If the wishes of the people consulted are going to be ignored, why bother with the expensive consultation at all?


Add Your Comment

Please note, it is the policy of The Shetland Times to publish comments and letters from named individuals only. Both forename and surname are required.

Comments are moderated. Contributors must observe normal standards of decency and tolerance for the opinions of others.

The views expressed are those of contributors and not of The Shetland Times.

The Shetland Times reserves the right to decline or remove any contribution without notice or stating reason.

Comments are limited to 200 words but please email longer articles or letters to editorial@shetlandtimes.co.uk for consideration and include a daytime telephone number and your address. If emailing information in confidence please put "Not for publication" in both the subject line and at the top of the main message.

200 words left

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


Get Latest News in Your Inbox

Join the The Shetland Times mailing list to get one daily email update at midday on what's happening in Shetland.