Charitable trust reforms envisage selection panel with independent chairman

Click on image to enlarge.

A majority of Shetland Charitable Trust trustees would be appointed by a selection panel and not councillor-trustees, under the latest proposals for reform published today.

Public comments are being invited on the recommendations of the trust’s governance review group, which was established after charities regulator OSCR requested that the £200 million organisation make itself more independent of the council.

The proposals envisage reducing the number of trustees from the current 23 (21 councillor-trustees and two independents) to 15 (seven councillor-trustees and eight appointed trustees). The selection panel would consist of an independent chairman from outwith Shetland “with a proven track record in a relevant field” and two trustees, at least one of whom would be, in the first instance, one of the existing independents and in future an appointee.

The chairman and vice-chairman of the trust would be chosen from among the appointees, who must live in Shetland and demonstrate that they have valuable skills and experience to help the trust promote economic and social development in Shetland.

Councillor-trustees would serve for the duration of their term as councillors and appointees from mid-point to mid-point of that term, with no trustee permitted to serve for more than two terms without a break of at least two years. The quorum would be six, with a minimum of three appointees.

In addition, there would be an annual general meeting open to the public and a requirement that trustees attend a minimum of half of all meetings.

If agreed at a special meeting of the trust on Wednesday 21st September, the reforms would end the stranglehold the council has had on the trust. But they are likely to disappoint those who have been calling for elections to the trust.

However one of those, independent trustee Sir John Scott, said he now accepted that this would be the best way forward.

“I am very pleased that the governance review group has come up with such a balance between public representation and personal ability. The electorate will be able to choose seven trustees through the council elections, while local people who wish to serve as trustees can put their names forward for selection,” he said.

“A majority of appointed trustees and an independent chair of the new trust will be a tremendous symbol of the new era that we are entering. The new structure will serve Shetland well.”

Trustees agreed to begin work on reform at a meeting back in February 2009, but were stymied when council convener Sandy Cluness, who was resistant to reform, won support for an independent legal opinion on the way forward, threatening to take the issue to the House of Lords.

Former Dean of the Faculty of Advocates Roy Martin QC delivered his opinion in the spring, recommending that the trust reform to end the scope for potential conflicts of interest and suggesting a balance of four councillor-trustees and 11 independents, although the final arithmetic, he said, was a matter for the trust itself.

Last month councillor-trustees Jonathan Wills and Gary Robinson spoke out following a seminar to discuss reform and condemned the unpublished proposals as “snobbery”, “funda­mentally anti-democratic” and “contemptuous and insulting” to the electorate.

In a letter to The Shetland Times today, Dr Wills said his “rational, evidence-based arguments” for elections had been ignored and claimed the trust would still be controlled by the council.

Trust chairman Bill Manson voiced his gratitude for the hard work of colleagues to come up with the comprehensive set of proposals.

“This has been a huge undertaking and I would like to thank the trustees who have put so much time and effort into this,” he said.

“We have sought public opinion and advice from experts in charity work and these proposals reflect the advice we have received. We want a transparent process of selecting the best people from the community to work alongside seven councillors who are elected by local voters.

“As trustees we carry a great responsibility for looking after Shetland’s community funds, and I believe the review group has struck the right balance between change and continuity.

“However we would still like to hear what the Shetland community thinks about these proposals and we invite comments to the trust before we make the final decision on 21st September.”

Details of the proposals can be found at and comments should be sent to or by post to 22-24 North Road, Lerwick, no later than 20th September. Comments received will be shared with all Trustees.


Add Your Comment
  • Alan Skinner

    • September 6th, 2011 13:08

    It seems to me that it is democracy that has got us into the mess in which SCT currently finds itself, so I applaud the selection committee with independent Chairman. However, we cannot ignore the fact that the elephant in the room is Viking Energy. In my view, anyone connected with Viking Energy, particularly Mr Manson, as Chairman of SCT and Viking Energy, cannot credibly be involved in the selection process. To be so, would inevitably taint the outcome of the selection process.
    One of the first tasks of the new trust board will be to review all existing investments and financial commitments. This will inevitably be a difficult and painful debate, and I do not envy the newly appointed Chairman.

    Alan Skinner

  • Marina Thomason

    • September 7th, 2011 9:36

    Why was the suggested split of 4 councillor trustees and 11 independents by Roy Martin QC ignored? With a 7 and 8 split the stranglehold by councillors on the charitable trust will only be lessened if there are more independents than councillors that turn up at meetings.


Add Your Comment

Please note, it is the policy of The Shetland Times to publish comments and letters from named individuals only. Both forename and surname are required.

Comments are moderated. Contributors must observe normal standards of decency and tolerance for the opinions of others.

The views expressed are those of contributors and not of The Shetland Times.

The Shetland Times reserves the right to decline or remove any contribution without notice or stating reason.

Comments are limited to 200 words but please email longer articles or letters to for consideration and include a daytime telephone number and your address. If emailing information in confidence please put "Not for publication" in both the subject line and at the top of the main message.

200 words left

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


Get Latest News in Your Inbox

Join the The Shetland Times mailing list to get one daily email update at midday on what's happening in Shetland.