Government investment insufficient to end mobile phone ‘not-spots’

A £150 million government investment aimed at improving mobile phone coverage in rural places such as Shetland will not go far enough to maintain the vital infrastructure needed for an adequate service.

That was the message from Shetland Telecom project manager Marvin Smith after the inaugural meeting this week of the Northern Isles digital forum.

Speaking after 40 people attended the Islesburgh Community Centre on Tuesday, Mr Smith said he welcomed the six-figure investment by the UK government, but he said more needed to be done if annoying “not-spots” in some places were to be eliminated in the long term.

Last year the coalition government announced plans to improve coverage across the UK by developing additional masts in rural areas. Chief secretary to the Treasury Danny Alexander said the aim was to enable rural users to have access not only to the 2G network, but 3G, while also providing a foundation for a future 4G upgrade.

Mr Smith said mobile phone operators had proved reluctant to set up masts in the isles given the relatively low numbers of customers they were likely to attract here – despite an apparent willingness from some operators to do business in the isles.

“The biggest concern for folk has been the mobile phone coverage. There was a scheme which allowed £150 million to help with mobile phone coverage in rural areas. But £150 million is not going to go very far, and the biggest problem for mobile phone operators is putting up a mast and getting the required revenue streams.

“If you are having to pay for connectivity to the mast and also carry out repairs and maintenance, £150 million for infrastructure isn’t actually that much. It’s early days. Nobody knows how it is going to be spent … but it’s not cheap.”

Mr Smith added a “longer conversation” needed to be had, perhaps at a future forum meeting, to help get round the problem.

But he said he was “encouraged” that a representative from the mobile phone industry had shown a willingness to visit the isles.

Richard Rumbelow, head of corporate affairs at mobile network Everything Everywhere, was another of the delegates attending Islesburgh this week. He was in the isles representing an association of mobile phone operators.

Also attending was Stuart Robertson from Highlands and Islands Enterprise. He told the meeting Shetland could not rely solely on private enterprise.

“I think the secret is the Highlands and Islands as a whole needs some level of public investment, as well as what the industry can bring.

“Unfortunately we have a small population over a large area and it doesn’t make for very good business for the private sector telecoms companies, so a mixture of private sector investment and from the public sector can certainly secure the types of technologies that we would like to see.

“It’s just a case of trying to get the funding in place, and the projects in place, to get these delivered.”

Tuesday’s forum had been organised by Isles MP Alistair Carmichael who receives frequent complaints about the level of broadband coverage in Shetland.

Mr Carmichael was keen to highlight an extra £10 million funding pot – budgeted as part of a £68 million block of UK government funding – to support high speed broadband roll out in Scotland.

Mr Carmichael said: “We’ve known for years that improving connectivity and getting access to digital services has been of crucial importance both socially and economically.

“What has changed is there is now a very different approach in government. For years we were told competition will provide, but frankly for us it never was going to provide and, surprise surprise, it has not.

“There is now a significant amount of public money going into the provision of digital services to meet some targets. It’s now important that, the money being there, the community should have a say in what sort of services they want out of it.”

Mr Smith added the need for better broadband was becoming increasingly apparent.

“Everybody is looking for super-fast connections. There are a few people sitting in extremely low spots or ‘not-spots’ and are not able to get broadband at all.”


Add Your Comment
  • Les Lowes

    • February 15th, 2012 22:23

    One answer could be to allow “roaming” in remoter areas, so consumers can make and receive mobile calls via any telecoms operator and they could share the cost of masts to eliminate not spots between them. Roaming was not encouraged in the UK as it would stifle competition. What we need is not greater competition but a better service!

    This whole area needs a good hard look at how to provide the services we need, using fibre optic and mobile technologies and involving government and local authority, BT, mobile operators getting together to find out how to achieve what’s needed.

  • Les Lowes

    • February 16th, 2012 15:11

    On the other hand, perhaps we should forget the kwangos and do what we did with TV transmitters in pre-satellite days; build our own mobile phone masts. It has been done in Wales by local communities and the mobile phone companies even lease space on the mast from the community company that owns it.


    We would probably get them quicker that way!


Add Your Comment

Please note, it is the policy of The Shetland Times to publish comments and letters from named individuals only. Both forename and surname are required.

Comments are moderated. Contributors must observe normal standards of decency and tolerance for the opinions of others.

The views expressed are those of contributors and not of The Shetland Times.

The Shetland Times reserves the right to decline or remove any contribution without notice or stating reason.

Comments are limited to 200 words but please email longer articles or letters to for consideration and include a daytime telephone number and your address. If emailing information in confidence please put "Not for publication" in both the subject line and at the top of the main message.

200 words left

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


Get Latest News in Your Inbox

Join the The Shetland Times mailing list to get one daily email update at midday on what's happening in Shetland.