New crofting representative backs MSP’s stance against Scottish government

Calls for greater democracy in the newly-formed Crofting Commission have been backed by Shetland’s representative. Kathleen Sinclair from Scous­burgh says any one of the six commissioners who were recently elected to the crofting body should act as its chairman.

Last week isles MSP Tavish Scott criticised the Scottish government for failing to allow crofting repres­entatives to choose their own leader. He said the SNP authority’s decision to appoint a chairman, rather than have one democratically elected, demonstrated a “domineering” interference.

Mrs Sinclair said on Wednesday she agreed with those views. She also criticised the government for allowing a delay of eight weeks to unfold before getting the commis­sion’s convener appointed to his or her post.

Although the new commission is largely made up of elected com­missioners, there are still three appointed representatives on the board even before the convener is put in place.

She said: “I think maybe what the com­missioners thought was that the convener would be appointed there and then, but that’s not the case. They are going to appoint the convener within eight weeks.

“Just now all our questions are going to the chief executive and until you have a convener I think the whole committee is not really complete.

“My personal view is that the convener should be one of the six commissioners that have been elect­ed by the crofters because they’re the folk who ken the practicalities involved in crofting. You have ones who ken about the rules and regulations but I think you need to have ones that ken about the prac­tical side as well.

“I have just spoken to a couple of the other commissioners and I think they would be in agreement with that. If you’re a crofter there are im­mense rules and regulations, foreby the crofting rules and regulations, with government schemes.”

The new commission replaces the old, similarly named Crofters Com­mis­sion, and enjoys extra powers designed to ensure crofting lands are occupied and worked on, or made available to those who want to croft.

The first task the new commis­sioners face is to approve a formal crofting commission interim plan which has been designed to set out the necessary rules and regulations surrounding the crofting sector. Mrs Sinclair said they had six months to put their input into that and put it back to the minister for approval.

One possible bone of contention within the plan concerns the assig­nation of crofts to people looking to take on small holdings.
Mrs Sinclair said guidelines cur­rently stipulated that the com­mission had final say over assignation. She would rather see leeway on that rule.

Commissioners must also decide whether area assessors who maintain a link between the commission and crofting communities should be retained. Mrs Sinclair said they were “very valuable”.

She reiterated her desire to see more young people coming into crofting, insisting it was crucial to get younger folk interested in the sector if crofting was to survive in the long-term.

“Crofting doesn’t make a lot of money. Most folk have to do a full-time job and come home to it. I know a few here that are doing a good job and I think any regulation has to support them. If it’s going to continue you must have young folk coming on. I would like the regulation to be more supportive of crofters.”

Some of the issues considered important down south are not considered important in Shetland. She said there was no problem here with absenteeism in crofts, although that could rear its head in other crofting communities.

One issue that may well be affecting other areas, however, is the question over windfarms. Asked for her view on the Viking Energy project, which was approved by the Scottish government last week, she said she was keen to gather opinions from the crofting community.

“I would be open to hear from any crofters regarding their views and concerns,” she added.


Add Your Comment
  • Johnny Sherwood

    • April 12th, 2012 22:39

    This is only the beginning. If you let that Central Belt SNP politicians take control of the Orkney/Shetlands, you’ll lose everything.


Add Your Comment

Please note, it is the policy of The Shetland Times to publish comments and letters from named individuals only. Both forename and surname are required.

Comments are moderated. Contributors must observe normal standards of decency and tolerance for the opinions of others.

The views expressed are those of contributors and not of The Shetland Times.

The Shetland Times reserves the right to decline or remove any contribution without notice or stating reason.

Comments are limited to 200 words but please email longer articles or letters to for consideration and include a daytime telephone number and your address. If emailing information in confidence please put "Not for publication" in both the subject line and at the top of the main message.

200 words left

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


Get Latest News in Your Inbox

Join the The Shetland Times mailing list to get one daily email update at midday on what's happening in Shetland.