Tough road ahead for fishermen when discard ban kicks in

George Eustice – the catch quota system has been tried successfully in England. Photo: Dave Donaldson
George Eustice – the catch quota system has been tried successfully in England. Photo: Dave Donaldson

Fishermen and industry leaders gave a lukewarm reception to a model of catch quotas floated by UK Fisheries Minister George Eustice at a meeting in Lerwick yesterday.

The minister outlined catch quotas as one of a number of “flexibilities” that are built into the “landing obligations” that will be applied to demersal fisheries from 2016, when haddock, cod, whiting and saithe can no longer be dumped at sea.

Shetland Fishermen’s Association chairman Leslie Tait said that while the visit from Mr Eustice, MP for Camborne and Redruth, was very welcome, the catch quota system had already been tried in Scotland and found wanting. Only one Shetland boat had participated in the voluntary scheme for a year and had decided not to repeat it.

Among the various unwelcome side effects of the catch quota scheme had been the very rapid doubling in cost of “renting” fish quota in Scotland. Under the scheme, boats that agree not to discard fish are awarded extra cod quota.

Shetland Fishermen's Association chairman Leslie Tait.
Shetland Fishermen’s Association chairman Leslie Tait.

The industry, Mr Tait said, is faced with the challenge of making something workable from a horrendously complicated set of proposals that will lead to a ban on discarding all species by 2020.

Mr Tait said: “This really is a guddle. There is a whole lot of stuff that will be interpreted in one way by one country and in another way by another country.”

The discard ban, intended to reduce fish mortality, promises a huge shake up for fishing practices but will also prove to be incredibly difficult for the industry to implement.

Local fishermen have reported having to dump hundreds of boxes of cod just to catch a few boxes of haddock “all around Shetland”. When the discard ban comes in, all fish will have to be landed.

The various “flexibilities” will only scratch the surface of quota shortages while the industry will be faced with tremendous administrative burdens.

After the meeting Mr Eustice said the catch quota system had been tried successfully in England. Other flexibilities include borrowing quota between different species or from the following year’s allocation or banking fish if not much was being caught. There would also be exemptions for fish like plaice that had a good chance of survival after discarding.

The controversial mackerel deal that will give Faroe a huge slice of the catch in perpetuity was also up for debate. Mr Eustice emphasised that a political settlement was inevitable and that almost doubling the UK mackerel quota – Shetland’s share this year will rise to 59,000 tonnes from 32,000 tonnes last year – will take the sting from settling with the Faroese.

But Mr Tait said the problem centered around future years when the quotas would inevitably contract given a decline in fish stocks. Then the UK fleet will be left with a greatly reduced share of the fishery.

There were precedents for this with blue whiting and Atlanto Scandian herring, where Britain had been left with very little of the stock.

There was also a question of how thoroughly Faroe would police its own fleet, given that the pelagic fisheries were now very toughly regulated in the EU.

In response to questions about the effects of Scottish independence, Mr Eustice said that the UK industry was now largely based in Scotland and was a top priority for UK negotiators. The industry in Shetland and Scotland would benefit from the extra votes the UK could bring to the negotiating table at the European Union.


Add Your Comment
  • Ali Inkster

    • June 4th, 2014 16:09

    How about this for an idea of how to save not only our fishing industry but our way of life.

    Full control of fishing operations with the EEZ (Exclusive economic zone )200 nm or to the median line with surrounding nations.
    1.)Complete abandonment of the quota system as enforced under the common fisheries policy, fish stocks to be maintained by the principle of controlling fishing time and effort (time on grounds and number of boats on grounds , in years where stocks are expected to be low permits to foreign vessels would be reduced or suspended)
    2.)All fish marketable fish caught must be landed, present minimum sizes to be maintained for all white fish species.

    3.)Pelagic sizes can be reduced to stop the pelagic fleet from dumping large volumes of under size catch, small mackerel and herring perfectly good for processing into canned products (Shetland catch to develop a cannery for this purpose)
    4.) All Shetland whitefish boats for future must be designed to incorporate refrigerated offal tanks, to increase production of fishmeal products (animal feeds and fertilizers, major upgrade to bressay factory)
    5.) Greater protection for inshore fishing using Faroese methods
    No trawling or seine netting within 12 miles april to September, 2 miles during winter months (subject to discussion and approval by local fleet)
    6) Foreign vessels to buy permits on trip by trip basis
    They get email approval that a permit is available.
    They must arrive at a Shetland quayside to open permit and undergo inspection of vessel and gear before commencement of fishing
    They must return to Shetland port upon completion of trip for inspection of catch
    Additional charge to sail home with catch ( encouragement to land on local markets, purchase local fuel and supplies etc, all taxable directly to shetalnd marine and fisheries department)
    Major upgrade for Shetland coastguards to monitor movements and activities of all foreign vessels, including financing shetand coastguard patrol vessel’s)
    All proceeds from permit sales used to re-invest in local marine sector and management)
    7.)Closed areas and system of marine protected zones developed, also with some coastal areas cleared of seal population to develop world class sea angling areas to develop highly desired areas for angling charter boats to operate.
    More to continue as thoughts develop…..


Add Your Comment

Please note, it is the policy of The Shetland Times to publish comments and letters from named individuals only. Both forename and surname are required.

Comments are moderated. Contributors must observe normal standards of decency and tolerance for the opinions of others.

The views expressed are those of contributors and not of The Shetland Times.

The Shetland Times reserves the right to decline or remove any contribution without notice or stating reason.

Comments are limited to 200 words but please email longer articles or letters to for consideration and include a daytime telephone number and your address. If emailing information in confidence please put "Not for publication" in both the subject line and at the top of the main message.

200 words left

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


Get Latest News in Your Inbox

Join the The Shetland Times mailing list to get one daily email update at midday on what's happening in Shetland.