Carmichael urges action over mobile ‘not-spots’

Greater co-operation between mobile network companies could help improve the signal in blighted areas – including large parts of Shetland.

That is the view of Northern Isles MP Alistair Carmichael who urged the communications firms to take action. He said that if the companies fail to address the situation the UK government will legislate to force them to do so.

His comments come after the Westminster culture secretary Sajid Javid published plans to consult on a proposal to allow mobile users to switch networks when they have no signal from their provider.

Overseas visitors can already use “roaming” facilities to switch to local networks in order to stay connected in so-called “not-spots”. Meanwhile the estimated one million Britons suffering from unreliable network coverage are not able to make use of the same provision.

Mr Carmichael said: “Loss of phone signal is something which we in the isles have all experienced and it is a source of great frustration for many. Local businesses, in particular, increasingly highlight this as an issue that holds them back.

“The solution here could lie in the hands of the mobile network operators themselves. If they would work together to share infrastructure such as masts then enormous improvements could be possible. If, however, they continue as they are doing then the government will act to force change. Mobile phone use is no longer a luxury but is regarded by many people these days as another utility.”

The lack of mobile phone coverage is worst in rural areas – where there is a lower density of customers – across the UK. According to figures supplied by

Mr Carmichael in Shetland more than a fifth (22.1 per cent) of the “geographical area” is served by just one provider, while 24 per cent is served by to. That means the total geographical area in partial not-spots is 46.1 per cent – the third highest in the UK.

Mr Carmichael said the latest proposals “would go some way towards tackling the problem of mobile ‘not-spots’ and it is disappointing that the larger mobile companies like Vodafone, 02, EE and Three have not been able to reach an agreement that will ultimately benefit mobile phone users across the UK.”

He added: “Travellers to the UK can already use roaming facilities to switch to local networks when they cannot access their usual provider. If mobile companies cannot reach an agreement with the government we will look to put mast sharing into law.”

Mr Javid’s proposal sparked reports in the national media that the idea was not supported by Home Secretary Theresa May, on national secutiry grounds.


Add Your Comment
  • Charlie Gallagher

    • November 5th, 2014 13:40

    To see below a ‘Press Release’ of 4th November 2014 from Mike McKenzie which I include for balance to your piece.
    Charlie Gallagher
    SNP – Shetland Branch.

    For immediate release: Tuesday 04 November


    Highlands and Islands MSP Mike MacKenzie today met with Education Scotland Officials to discuss the SIC’s proposals to close schools in Shetland.

    MacKenzie is now calling for a moratorium on all the education proposals at least until the new Anderson High is complete. This call comes just one day after Councillors in Moray impose a 5 year moratorium on school closures in similar circumstances.

    MacKenzie commented:

    “Following a visit to Shetland at the weekend I have welcomed today’s decision from Shetland Island Councillors concerning Urafrith and North Roe schools but I am nevertheless now calling for a moratorium on all the education proposals.”

    “At my meeting today, Education Scotland officials confirmed that Curriculum for Excellence is sufficiently flexible to be compatible with Shetland’s current model for education. They confirmed this despite having made the point with regard to previous proposals and stressed that each case is different; so Shetland Island Council cannot blame or hide behind Education Scotland”


    “I have examined the proposals from a financial and economic perspective as well as from an educational perspective and along with many concerned parents can find little merit in the proposals. I can conclude only that the consultation process has been so badly handled as to be irretrievably blighted.”

    The Council urgently needs to offer an olive branch to communities and now must begin the process of rebuilding trust. Only then would it be possible to have sensible discussions with parents, children and everyone affected by any changes to Shetland’s education system.

    “Moray Councillors have yesterday shown they have the courage and common sense to impose a 5 year moratorium on school closures in similar circumstances. Shetland’s Councillors could and should now do the same.”

    0131 348 5057

    • Gordon Harmer

      • November 5th, 2014 19:50

      Not very well balanced Charlie, as I think your hot-spot is not a not-spot nor is it in the right-spot as Alistair is talking about not-spots which renders your rather hurried and point scoring press release somewhat IRRETRIEVABLY BLIGHTED. Come to think of it, a bit like your failed independence campaign.


Add Your Comment

Please note, it is the policy of The Shetland Times to publish comments and letters from named individuals only. Both forename and surname are required.

Comments are moderated. Contributors must observe normal standards of decency and tolerance for the opinions of others.

The views expressed are those of contributors and not of The Shetland Times.

The Shetland Times reserves the right to decline or remove any contribution without notice or stating reason.

Comments are limited to 200 words but please email longer articles or letters to for consideration and include a daytime telephone number and your address. If emailing information in confidence please put "Not for publication" in both the subject line and at the top of the main message.

200 words left

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


Get Latest News in Your Inbox

Join the The Shetland Times mailing list to get one daily email update at midday on what's happening in Shetland.