Scalloway man spared jail after ‘vicious assault’ in village house

A man who launched a vicious assault against a defence­less victim was spared a prison sentence this week after a sheriff was told he needed to look after his mother.

Instead, Gordon Keith, 46, of Meadowfield Crescent in Scalloway, was ordered to carry out 300 hours of unpaid work – the maximum level that can be imposed.

Keith previously admitted attack­ing his 59-year-old victim at an address in the village last September.

The emergency services were called after the man was spotted by a passer-by. The victim was taken to hospital, where he was kept overnight.

Lerwick Sheriff Court previously heard the com­plainer had said some­thing “innocuous” that Keith had taken exception to.

Procurator fiscal Duncan MacKenzie had described the attack as a “vicious assault” against the “defenceless” man, who had lain obviously injured with his head on a sofa after the attack. Sentence had been deferred for background reports to be com­piled.

At Wednesday’s court, sheriff Philip Mann was handed references in support of Keith.

Defence agent Tommy Allan also handed him a letter from Keith’s victim, adding it appeared to suggest the complainer had forgiven him for the offence.

“He’s apologised to the com­plain­­er and it would seem from the letter that the complainer has accept­ed that apology,” Mr Allan said.

The agent highlighted the social work report which stated Keith was relied upon by his mother. He argued imposing an alternative to custody would mean Keith could make some reparation to the com­munity and still be able to provide assistance to her.

“You’ll see he has a very lengthy record. He is some­one who, at one point, was a fairly regular visitor to this building, but his situation has improved in recent years,” said Mr Allan.

“There is scope to deal with Mr Keith without using the powers the court has to put him in prison. He is very much aware that that could be the disposal today.”

The sheriff admitted his mind was swayed at the last moment.

“There is no doubt at all this offence, coupled with your record, could amply merit a custodial sentence, and it is something I have very seriously considered,” he told Keith.

“Before coming on to the bench today, that was probably my pro­visional intention. However, having regard to what’s been said on your behalf I’m persuaded I can give you an opportunity here, but it is one you’ve got to grasp.”

He allowed Keith one year in which to complete the hours of work



Get Latest News in Your Inbox

Join the The Shetland Times mailing list to get one daily email update at midday on what's happening in Shetland.