Stout defends record after ‘all mouth and no trousers’ claim made over ferry service

A councillor has defended the SIC’s record on ferries after a claim the service was proving too inflexible for vulnerable communities.

Chairman of the environment and transport committee, Michael Stout, has spoken after the head of Bressay’s community council argued pleas to make the service more adaptable to changing needs had been met with silence.

Alistair Christie-Henry described the SIC as “all mouth and no trousers”, insisting folk in Bressay had been unable to work on the construction of the new Total gas plant because ferry times were not adapted to suit. While other ferry routes operate from as early as 6.15am, the Bressay route does not get going until 7am – too late for some to bear.

Mr Christie-Henry said Bressay folk were effectively told “don’t rock the boat” while discussions are held with Transport Scotland over plans for the SNP government to absorb ferry costs, as it does in other island groups.

He said a more flexible approach could have prevented people from leaving Bressay altogether.
He believes Bressay’s population has dropped from 400, way back when fixed links were being discussed as a possible solution, to a little over 300 now.

The changes have left Bressay facing a critical situation despite the efforts of an on-island development body – which aims to reverse the island’s poor fortunes – in recent years.

There are three vacancies on the Bressay Community Council, which have remained stubbornly in place over recent years.

“Bressay exists on its ferry service and if we don’t have a ferry service, Bressay will never survive,” Mr Christie-Henry said.

“The council progresses so slowly when it comes to transport development. My former colleagues on the council will see that as my ‘criticism for [Michael] Craigie’ agenda, but it’s all mouth and no trousers at the council.

We’ve been told for years about how it can benefit Bressay, but the council has done nothing to help – ALISTAIR CHRISTIE-HENRY

“We’ve been told for years about how it can benefit Bressay, but the council has done nothing to help.

“It’s a case of ‘let’s wait to see what the Scottish government will do with our ferry service’. But we’ve been waiting two years for that.

“There comes a point where you have to say the youth of the isle has gone. There’s a gap in our community where teenagers say ‘we’ve finished our apprenticeships, thanks very much, but we’re not going to be biding in Bressay any more’.

“How do we then persuade the council that circumstances have changed and we need a ferry that changes to circumstances? We need a ferry at six o-clock in the morning. We also need a ferry to end at an expected finish time. But there is no provision in there, and there is no vision in the council to say how can we adapt it, how can we amend it?”

He said his comments were not a criticism against the operation of the ferry service or those in charge of the vessels.

“The promise is always there. ‘We’re talking to Transport Scotland and SNP government to absorb the costs of ferry services don’t rock the boat in the meantime’.”

However, Mr Stout said the SIC had “consistently discussed and picked up on” the issue surrounding the ferry service, and the difficulties faced in Bressay.

Michael Stout
Michael Stout

“The whole bottom line is there is a vast amount of work gone in to the transport issues as much as anything else in Bressay.

“To use the example of the Total gas work – fine, if there had been the early ferry there could have been potential for some folk in Bressay to get some of that work.

“However, the reality was nobody moved from Bressay anyway to go and get that work. There is the overall population decline and there is the elderly population.”

Mr Stout said the community council in Bressay and the development association needed to “do the work, come up with the evidence and work out what the overall community wants”. He argued a “consistent plan” was needed for what the future development needs in Bressay were.

“So, for example, if you’re aiming to get more working folk coming into the place, it could well be that having an early ferry to access work would be a useful thing. But let’s have a genuine consultation and a genuine sense of what the community wants before you spend money on it.”

Mr Stout added the debate came against a background of ongoing work aimed at getting the Scottish government to fully fund ferries.

He said a business case was needed for the Bressay service to be expanded.

“The reality is what’s already been done and what’s happened around the full funding for the ferries is a sight more than what’s ever been done before. We are going in the right direction with this.”

Mr Christie-Henry said the community council was trying to remain positive about potential developments in the future. A transport sub-committee is examining how transport services can be piloted in the island. But a previous demographic study by Bressay’s development association is being looked at “in the round” again.

“The difficulty we have is that we have a community with a rapidly declining population, and a rapidly ageing population.

“We thought in the hey-day when we were looking at fixed links to Bressay a population that was fetching up to 400. Since that heady days and expectations it’s declined to, I think, the population would now be below 320.”

He said the community needed to know more about how to address its long-term needs, in particular how it might serve its older men and women.

“There are no carers resident in the island. So we’re looking at, if we have 100-plus over the age of 60, and it looks like that’s a trend that’s increasing, then what are our needs going to be?

“The community council identified there is that need. There was a short term working group within the community council set up to look into that and ask the questions ‘do we need to have a care home?’ for example, ‘do we need a resident carer?’ do we need a drop in centre.

“A care centre wouldn’t be realistic, certainly not from the public sector, but when you look at private nursing care which is alien to Shetland it works out.

“It’s thinking out of the box, which is what we need to do.”


Add Your Comment
  • John Tulloch

    • January 21st, 2017 13:26

    Considering Councillor Stout’s Lerwick North ward includes Bressay, I find his reported comment astonishing:

    ‘“To use the example of the Total gas work – fine, if there had been the early ferry there could have been potential for some folk in Bressay to get some of that work.

    “However, the reality was nobody moved from Bressay anyway to go and get that work.”

    Nobody left Bressay to work at Total, so everything is hunky dory? No, not really, Michael.

    This sets out the council’s attitude to Shetland’s island populations, from its depute leader and chieftain of transport issues.

    So much for the much-vaunted “Tackling Inequalities” commission!

  • Christopher Johnston

    • January 22nd, 2017 8:40

    Meanwhile, Shetlanders concern themselves with silly causes like marching against Trump while not resolving pressing local issues like ferries, Viking Energy, OIOF, and SCT governance.
    It reminds me of young children with a new puppy who ignore the pile the puppy left in the corner because they would have to clean up the pile if they acknowledge it exists.


      • January 22nd, 2017 14:06

      Christopher, these comments are going off-topic but it’s important to say here that the marches this weekend were aimed at standing up against the sexism, racism and homophobia associated with Trump’s presidential campaign, not simply him as a person. Those are incredibly important issues – not a “silly”matter at all.

      • Christopher Johnston

        • January 22nd, 2017 19:32

        Robert, I voted for Trump and researched these “issues” you cite for myself before voting. I satisfied myself that they are bogus and so I challenge you to prove what you state by citing exactly what Trump said, the context in which Trump said it, and when Trump said it. Please list your data and sources in full.
        As for my use of “silly”, silly is exactly what I mean. Shetlanders protest something not directly affecting them and over which they have no control, while not focusing on important Shetland issues directly affecting them and over which they have some control. You didn’t like our former President Obama intruding into your Brexit vote by lecturing you on how you must vote, did you? And you didn’t see US folk demonstrating against the Brexit vote and the UK politicians, did you?

  • Ian Tinkler

    • January 22nd, 2017 20:55

    Robert Sim; “Sexism, racism and homophobia” funny, I thought the protest was about Trump, not most of the world’s religions! The adds were about Trump. I may have gone if it was “Sexism, racism and homophobia”, but then it was aimed at women only, pink pussy hats and all!! hows that for sexism.


Add Your Comment

Please note, it is the policy of The Shetland Times to publish comments and letters from named individuals only. Both forename and surname are required.

Comments are moderated. Contributors must observe normal standards of decency and tolerance for the opinions of others.

The views expressed are those of contributors and not of The Shetland Times.

The Shetland Times reserves the right to decline or remove any contribution without notice or stating reason.

Comments are limited to 200 words but please email longer articles or letters to for consideration and include a daytime telephone number and your address. If emailing information in confidence please put "Not for publication" in both the subject line and at the top of the main message.

200 words left

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


Get Latest News in Your Inbox

Join the The Shetland Times mailing list to get one daily email update at midday on what's happening in Shetland.