Nugent warns SNP conference: ditch the EU or lose supporters

The SNP should drop its support for EU membership, according to a leading member in the party’s local branch who spoke out at the national conference.

Yes Shetland minutes secretary Brian Nugent believes his party risks losing any future referendum on independence if it fails to change tack.

The 65-year-old – a relief porter at the Gilbert Bain hospital – points to the statistic that one-third of SNP voters opted for Leave in the Brexit referendum of 2016.

At the party’s conference in Glasgow on Sunday, he said: “Voters are not a tap to be turned on and off. If the SNP keep promoting an issue that the voters are not in favour of, then those voters might find others to vote for. And when it comes to Indyref2, when every vote will count, can we be sure that those Leave voters will just, automatically, come back on side?”

The SNP’s annual conference took place in Glasgow’s SEC (formerly the SECC) between Sunday and Tuesday.

Mr Nugent, from Hamnavoe, Burra, was one of a handful of Shetlanders to make the trip south.

On the opening day of the event, attendees were invited to acknowledge some of the perceived benefits of EU membership.

However, Mr Nugent quickly put himself at odds with the majority of the party faithful by calling for the resolution to be rejected.

He told his colleagues in the main chamber: “After the Brexit vote, we have a problem. One in three SNP voters voted to Leave. In moving the remit back, I am asking us to consider a different policy with regards to the EU.”

He added that he is opposed to the EU – but not because of immigration reasons. Rather, his view is based on the belief that “there is no democracy in the EU”.

Yet despite Mr Nugent’s best efforts, his intervention failed to persuade the room and a majority leant their support to the EU resolution.

Shetland South councillor Robbie McGregor, who was also at the conference, missed Mr Nugent’s contribution – but later told The Shetland Times that he disagrees with his fellow SNP supporter on the subject of the EU.

He said: “My position is that I’m a total Europhile and I very much look forward to independence for Scotland in the European Union.

“But we are a democratic party and Brian has a different view from what I have and is perfectly entitled to express that view even though I do not agree with it.”

He added: “We have to have connections with Europe, and Brexit is an absolute shambles and I believe it’s going to be against the interests of both the fishing community and the agricultural community in Shetland.”

Shetland’s SNP candidate in June’s general election, Miriam Brett, finished in second place with 6,749 votes – almost 5,000 fewer than winning candidate Alistair Carmichael (Liberal Democrats).

In the Scottish independence referendum of 2014, only 36 per cent of Shetlanders backed the Yes side.

The Shetland Times attempted to contact Yes Shetland chairman Iain Malcolmson for comment.


Add Your Comment
  • Graham Fleming

    • October 13th, 2017 21:31

    There are many forms of self government that could be for Scotland in or out of the U.K in or out of the E.U,Republic or monarchy, in or not in Nato etc.etc.With the re-stablishment of the Scottish parliament 20 years ago, we have record employment, second only to the independent Czech Republic,Scotland an exporting nation would be very unwise to be outwith the single market.Every avenue has to be explored to keep the status quo.

    • ian tinkler

      • October 15th, 2017 9:13

      “,Scotland an exporting nation would be very unwise to be outwith the single market”. What pure humbug from Fleming. Scotlands single biggest market is the UK, yet Graham is a “fundamentalist Scot Natty separatist”. This is pure hypocrisy. Graham supporting the “status quo”, pull the other one please Graham, your logic is pure SNP..

  • John Tulloch

    • October 14th, 2017 8:25

    Mr Nugent’s forthright honesty is, indeed, refreshing.

  • David Spence

    • October 15th, 2017 0:36

    I would be interested in Brian’s alternative to Scotland being independent and not part of the EU (I suspect the EU Ref. was rigged and fixed for other reasons, and nothing to do with the EU……..and more to do with the USA, lets say).

    What would Brian’s alternative be to not being in the EU……….have an alliance with the USA on the USA’s terms and conditions (just like the Tories) and allowing US companies to sue Local Authorities or the Government if things do not go their way ????

    Would Brian’s Scotland favour ‘ private market forces ‘ to control everything to do with Scotland in terms of its economics, but have little power to do anything about it because ‘ market forces would have greater control ‘ than political establishment (just like it is in the USA)????

    Would Brian’s Scotland favour a political system which is dependent, 100%, on bribery, favours and backdoor dealings, which are far more corrupt than the EU could ever be (just like the USA)????

    What would Brian’s Scotland be in supporting those in society which need the greatest help, health, education and many other functions and services done by the state???????

  • Bill Adams

    • October 17th, 2017 13:27

    I’m surprised the journalist writing this article omits to mention the fact
    that Shetland voted by 56.5 to 43.5 per cent to remain in the EU .

    • Ali Inkster

      • October 18th, 2017 21:12

      We voted in far greater numbers to remain in the UK and the UK voted to leave the EU. That’s the problem when we are attached to a larger entity we have to go where they take us.

  • ian tinkler

    • October 18th, 2017 22:28

    Why am I not surprised, Bill Adams, you never mentioned, Shetland voted 64% to 36% to remain in the UK.
    Note Benne, The UK voted for Brexit, now get over it.


Add Your Comment

Please note, it is the policy of The Shetland Times to publish comments and letters from named individuals only. Both forename and surname are required.

Comments are moderated. Contributors must observe normal standards of decency and tolerance for the opinions of others.

The views expressed are those of contributors and not of The Shetland Times.

The Shetland Times reserves the right to decline or remove any contribution without notice or stating reason.

Comments are limited to 200 words but please email longer articles or letters to for consideration and include a daytime telephone number and your address. If emailing information in confidence please put "Not for publication" in both the subject line and at the top of the main message.

200 words left

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


Get Latest News in Your Inbox

Join the The Shetland Times mailing list to get one daily email update at midday on what's happening in Shetland.